"The results kind of immediately spoke for themselves. We generated about 15 new opportunities worth of over $100,000 in pipeline. The biggest impact for us was really giving us time back... The Cymate team was really there to help us every step of the way."
BACKGROUND.
Eventual Treasury is an AI-powered revenue operations platform built specifically for insurance brokerages and agencies. The platform automates the time-consuming and error-prone process of commission reconciliation, cash application, and revenue tracking.
The product's core value lies in using proprietary AI to match carrier statements to policy records across direct bill and agency bill commissions, automatically updating Agency Management Systems (AMS) and ERP general ledgers in real-time. This functionality enables brokers to recover missing revenue, eliminate manual data entry, and streamline financial reporting, shifting accounting teams from reactive reconciliation to strategic revenue growth.
Prior to engaging with Cymate, Eventual Treasury struggled to build a predictable outbound channel, as validated by Elan's experience:
Deliverability Crisis: Despite trying various outreach methods, "our emails were just not getting into the right inboxes and we just weren't able from a deliverability standpoint to make sure that our emails were again being delivered..."
Time and Resource Drain: Managing the lead generation channel internally was a massive burden, preventing the early-stage team from focusing on "more strategic initiatives" and closing high-value deals.
Market Specificity: The initial broad targeting was inefficient. The team quickly realized they needed specialized messaging based on the client's core tech stack, requiring surgical precision around which AMS the agency used (e.g., Applied Epic, Vertafore, EZLynx).
THE SOLUTION.
Cymate deployed a highly resilient, full-stack outbound ecosystem built for maximum scale, high deliverability, and continuous strategic iteration.
Infrastructure, Scale, and Resilience
The system was designed to handle high volume and rapid change:
Massive Initial Deployment: The initial setup included 33 dedicated domains and 100 inboxes configured and warmed up in under four weeks.
Zero-Downtime Rebuild: When Elan transitioned out, necessitating a sender change, Cymate immediately halted outreach, rebuilt the entire sender profile, and deployed an even larger system of 48 domains and 145 inboxes under the new sender's name in less than 2.5 weeks.
Proactive Health Maintenance: When a deliverability audit later flagged minor dips (September), an additional 10 domains and 30 inboxes were preemptively created and warmed up to maintain high inbox health and outbound volume.
Data-Driven Iteration and Strategy
Strategy was continuously refined using real-time performance metrics and deep collaboration:
Targeting by AMS: Campaigns were launched specific to Vertafore, Applied Epic, and EZLynx users, proving that AMS-specific messaging drove engagement. The EZLynx campaign notably achieved the highest response rates, which were then leveraged to optimize copy for re-engaging AMS360 users.
Refining the ICP: Initial feedback led to immediate adjustments, filtering out poor-fit segments (Medicare-focused agencies, InsurTechs) to focus strictly on mid-to-large P&C agencies with over $500k in revenue.
Testing and Elimination: Multiple copy variants were continuously A/B tested. The team quickly identified and turned off underperforming messaging (such as the Leavitt press release variant in August) to ensure maximum return on outreach volume.
Eventual Treasury established a highly effective GTM channel, consistently achieving high engagement and reclaiming valuable internal resources.
Pipeline & Opportunity Generation: The campaign immediately generated 15 new opportunities worth over $100,000 in pipeline value.
Elite Campaign Performance: The AMS-specific focus yielded top-performing campaigns (EZLynx users) that achieved a positive reply rate of 25%, far exceeding industry benchmarks.
Strategic Time Reclamation: The partnership enabled the GTM leader to "take a lot of the stress away" from manual lead generation, allowing the team to focus on closing big deals and core product development.
more Case Studies.
Software Company
From 10 to 35+ Meetings a Month in a Niche Most Outbound Agencies Can't Crack
Grasshopper Kids was running cold email in-house and capped at 10 meetings a month, hitting a hard ceiling on a fragmented buyer pool spanning Principals, Enrichment Directors, PTA leaders, and grant-funded Community School Coordinators. Cymate took over end-to-end, including reply management, and lifted them to 35+ qualified meetings a month, with one record stretch booking 12 meetings in 3 days.
Read case study
Software Company
Quadrupling Your Pipeline Revenue in Less Than 2 Weeks
How we achieved a 4x in booking rate for Revv’s sales team in less than 2 weeks.
Read case study